News

Keir Starmer risks shredding Tories’ hard-fought Brexit win on animals in EU deal

Keir Starmer and Zac Goldsmith
Zac Goldsmith has slammed Keir Starmer (Image: Getty)

Zac Goldsmith has slammed Keir Starmer’s UK-EU reset for risking the Tories hard-fought Brexit wins on animal welfare. The environmentalist warned that a “troubling commitment” in the agreement means any UK deviation from EU food standards must not “negatively affect European Union animals and goods being placed on the market” in the UK.

The former MP said: “This seemingly technical clause has profound implications for animal welfare and our ability to raise our own standards, something that we fought so hard to achieve with Brexit.  “Among other things it likely means the UK cannot restrict imports of animal products that fail to meet our welfare standards – even when we’ve banned those same practices domestically.

As part of the agreement he signed, there will be more targeted checks on the movement of animals, animal products, plants and other products.

This will stop animals being held for excessive periods at the borders and lower any detrimental impact on animal health and welfare, and reduce the burden on the veterinary workforce.

There was also a commitment made on shared disease surveillance and data sharing, which will secure UK biosecurity and risk of imported diseases.

Animal welfare groups also welcomed the introduction of pet passports to replace Animal Health Certificates (AHCs), which increased burden on the veterinary workforce and hiked costs for animal owners since they came into force.

A Government spokesman said: “This government will always act in the national interest to protect Britain’s farmers and secure our food security. We have said we will uphold the highest agricultural standards and that is exactly what this deal does.”

By Lord Zac Goldsmith

Brexit undoubtedly delivered meaningful wins for animals, enabling policy changes that were previously impossible. We were able for example to ban the cruel live export of animals for slaughter and even more far reaching, we could change the way we subsidised farming to incentivise higher animal welfare and environmental stewardship. Neither of these changes could have happened without Brexit, which is one of the reasons I supported our EU exit in 2016.

And although of course I wish we had done more, the last Conservative Government did deliver a wide range of animal welfare measures, from an expanded ivory ban and banning glue traps, to much bigger sentences for animal cruelty and recognising sentience in law. Now in Opposition the Party is calling for among other things raising zoo standards.

Last month’s UK-EU Summit produced a ‘Common Understanding’ agreement which has been hailed by the Prime Minister as a significant step towards mending post-Brexit relations, generating economic benefits and streamlining trade. However, buried in the details lies a troubling commitment: any UK deviation from EU food standards must not “negatively affect European Union animals and goods being placed on the market in the United Kingdom”.

This seemingly technical clause has profound implications for animal welfare and our ability to raise our own standards, something that we fought so hard to achieve with Brexit. Among other things it likely means the UK cannot restrict imports of animal products that fail to meet our welfare standards – even when we’ve banned those same practices domestically.

Consider the immediate threats. Around 50% of UK pork imports come from EU countries still using sow stalls – narrow metal cages we banned in the 90s because they were considered to be cruel. The last Labour government prohibited fur farming in the UK, yet we continue importing it from the EU. Under the new agreement, banning such imports may be impossible, despite the stated wishes of the Government to deliver the biggest boost to animal welfare in a generation.

The agreement links UK standards to EU animal welfare rules with opt outs limited to public health and biosecurity – assessed case by case basis. So while we might still be able to ban puppy imports, as these present a public health risk, the agreement could block us from banning EU fur or even foie gras on welfare grounds alone.

This not only undermines domestic animal welfare standards but also places British farmers, who adhere to stricter regulations, at a competitive disadvantage. The problem is more acute with EU imports, our largest trading partner for food imports, not just the usual suspects like the USA or Australia.

Brexit gave us the chance to lead the world on animal welfare – to show that an independent Britain could set gold standards that others would follow. This is also about democratic sovereignty; British voters consistently support higher animal welfare standards, with 84% backing restrictions on low-welfare imports.

There’s still time to put this right, but it will require government to clarify that animal welfare measures fall outside the SPS Agreement’s scope, or to negotiate explicit exceptions for welfare-based restrictions.

While its proponents say the UK-EU reset agreement offers economic and diplomatic benefits, it’s imperative that animal welfare remains a priority. By addressing these concerns proactively, the UK can position itself as a global leader in animal welfare and ensure that progress is not achieved at the expense of the most vulnerable and the voiceless.

Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer (Image: Getty)

Sir Keir Starmer has suffered a major political setback after a fresh analysis suggested his personal ratings are among the worst of any modern Prime Minister – prompting Reform UK leader Nigel Farage to claim there is “no way back” for him. Mr Farage’s remarks, made after Sir Keir announced a national grooming gang inquiry in an apparent U-turn, followed an update from Britain Elects, whose rolling tracker compares the popularity of serving Prime Ministers over their first 300 days in office.

Posting on X, the Reform UK leader declared: “It doesn’t matter how many U-turns Starmer does. He is unpopular because he is insincere. There is no way back for him.” The analysis found: “Compared to past Prime Ministers, Starmer’s start is a poor one. As of day 300, Starmer ranked the worst performing Prime Minister of the last nine (once you exclude, of course, Liz Truss).”

DON’T MISS
Powered by 
Rachel Reeves dealt devastating poll blow as Angela Rayner handed huge boost
Rachel Reeves dealt devastating poll blow as Angela Rayner handed huge boost

Comments

Zia Yusuf plots political domination with bid to become Reform UK's sixth MP
Zia Yusuf plots political domination with bid to become Reform UK’s sixth MP

Comments

Nigel Farage's jaw drops as Rachel Reeves delivers shocking insult
Nigel Farage’s jaw drops as Rachel Reeves delivers shocking insult

Comments

Sadiq Khan sparks speculation of Keir Starmer coup as he addresses career future
Sadiq Khan sparks speculation of Keir Starmer coup as he addresses career future

Comments

Rachel Reeves just dropped biggest clue yet Labour fears Nigel Farage and Reform UK
Rachel Reeves just dropped biggest clue yet Labour fears Nigel Farage and Reform UK

Comments

POLL: Should Nigel Farage get a knighthood in King Charles's Birthday Honours
POLL: Should Nigel Farage get a knighthood in King Charles’s Birthday Honours

Comments

Keir Starmer's U-turns explained - from Winter Fuel Payments to WASPI women
Keir Starmer’s U-turns explained – from Winter Fuel Payments to WASPI women

Comments

I was in the room when Kemi's Badenoch's right-hand man took on the Liz Truss era
I was in the room when Kemi’s Badenoch’s right-hand man took on the Liz Truss era

Comments

Angela Rayner and Rachel Reeves descend into furious civil war over spending cuts
Angela Rayner and Rachel Reeves descend into furious civil war over spending cuts

Comments

Reform MP calls for burqa ban in PMQs bombshell as Keir Starmer left stunned
Reform MP calls for burqa ban in PMQs bombshell as Keir Starmer left stunned

Comments

Rachel Reeves set for axe as 'vultures circle' after terrible week for UK economy
Rachel Reeves set for axe as ‘vultures circle’ after terrible week for UK economy

Comments

Nigel Farage plans to bring stars of business, TV and sports into his Cabinet as PM
Nigel Farage plans to bring stars of business, TV and sports into his Cabinet as PM

Comments

Keir Starmer jets off to Canada as Middle East chaos overshadows trade deal talks
Keir Starmer jets off to Canada as Middle East chaos overshadows trade deal talks

Comments

Rachel Reeves makes huge admission over winter fuel payment cut in bombshell clip
Rachel Reeves makes huge admission over winter fuel payment cut in bombshell clip

Comments

Rachel Reeves makes it easy for Kemi Badenoch to ask one question over and over
Rachel Reeves makes it easy for Kemi Badenoch to ask one question over and over

Comments

Politics LIVE: Keir Starmer faces fury over grooming gangs scandal
Politics LIVE: Keir Starmer faces fury over grooming gangs scandal

Comments

Rachel Reeves's bright ideas have taken a matter of hours to crumble
Rachel Reeves’s bright ideas have taken a matter of hours to crumble

Comments

Fury as Keir Starmer refuses to apologise to pensioners over winter fuel chaos
Fury as Keir Starmer refuses to apologise to pensioners over winter fuel chaos

Comments

Rachel Reeves takes desperate dig at Nigel Farage after winter fuel fiasco
Rachel Reeves takes desperate dig at Nigel Farage after winter fuel fiasco

Comments

Nine million pensioners to receive winter fuel payment after government u-turn on policy
Nine million pensioners to receive winter fuel payment after government u-turn on policy

Comments

Rachel Reeves dealt devastating poll blow as Angela Rayner handed huge boost
Rachel Reeves dealt devastating poll blow as Angela Rayner handed huge boost

Comments

Zia Yusuf plots political domination with bid to become Reform UK's sixth MP
Zia Yusuf plots political domination with bid to become Reform UK’s sixth MP

Comments

Nigel Farage's jaw drops as Rachel Reeves delivers shocking insult
Nigel Farage’s jaw drops as Rachel Reeves delivers shocking insult

Comments

Sadiq Khan sparks speculation of Keir Starmer coup as he addresses career future
Sadiq Khan sparks speculation of Keir Starmer coup as he addresses career future

Comments

Rachel Reeves just dropped biggest clue yet Labour fears Nigel Farage and Reform UK
Rachel Reeves just dropped biggest clue yet Labour fears Nigel Farage and Reform UK

Comments

POLL: Should Nigel Farage get a knighthood in King Charles's Birthday Honours
POLL: Should Nigel Farage get a knighthood in King Charles’s Birthday Honours

Comments

Keir Starmer's U-turns explained - from Winter Fuel Payments to WASPI women
Keir Starmer’s U-turns explained – from Winter Fuel Payments to WASPI women

Comments

I was in the room when Kemi's Badenoch's right-hand man took on the Liz Truss era
I was in the room when Kemi’s Badenoch’s right-hand man took on the Liz Truss era

Comments

Angela Rayner and Rachel Reeves descend into furious civil war over spending cuts
Angela Rayner and Rachel Reeves descend into furious civil war over spending cuts

Comments

Reform MP calls for burqa ban in PMQs bombshell as Keir Starmer left stunned
Reform MP calls for burqa ban in PMQs bombshell as Keir Starmer left stunned

Comments

Rachel Reeves set for axe as 'vultures circle' after terrible week for UK economy
Rachel Reeves set for axe as ‘vultures circle’ after terrible week for UK economy

Comments

Nigel Farage plans to bring stars of business, TV and sports into his Cabinet as PM
Nigel Farage plans to bring stars of business, TV and sports into his Cabinet as PM

Comments

Keir Starmer jets off to Canada as Middle East chaos overshadows trade deal talks
Keir Starmer jets off to Canada as Middle East chaos overshadows trade deal talks

Comments

Rachel Reeves makes huge admission over winter fuel payment cut in bombshell clip
Rachel Reeves makes huge admission over winter fuel payment cut in bombshell clip

Comments

Rachel Reeves makes it easy for Kemi Badenoch to ask one question over and over
Rachel Reeves makes it easy for Kemi Badenoch to ask one question over and over

Comments

Politics LIVE: Keir Starmer faces fury over grooming gangs scandal
Politics LIVE: Keir Starmer faces fury over grooming gangs scandal

Comments

Rachel Reeves's bright ideas have taken a matter of hours to crumble
Rachel Reeves’s bright ideas have taken a matter of hours to crumble

Comments

Fury as Keir Starmer refuses to apologise to pensioners over winter fuel chaos
Fury as Keir Starmer refuses to apologise to pensioners over winter fuel chaos

Comments

Rachel Reeves takes desperate dig at Nigel Farage after winter fuel fiasco
Rachel Reeves takes desperate dig at Nigel Farage after winter fuel fiasco

Comments

Nine million pensioners to receive winter fuel payment after government u-turn on policy
Nine million pensioners to receive winter fuel payment after government u-turn on policy

Comments

Rachel Reeves dealt devastating poll blow as Angela Rayner handed huge boost
Rachel Reeves dealt devastating poll blow as Angela Rayner handed huge boost

Comments

Zia Yusuf plots political domination with bid to become Reform UK's sixth MP
Zia Yusuf plots political domination with bid to become Reform UK’s sixth MP

Comments

Nigel Farage's jaw drops as Rachel Reeves delivers shocking insult
Nigel Farage’s jaw drops as Rachel Reeves delivers shocking insult

Comments

Sadiq Khan sparks speculation of Keir Starmer coup as he addresses career future
Sadiq Khan sparks speculation of Keir Starmer coup as he addresses career future

Comments

Rachel Reeves just dropped biggest clue yet Labour fears Nigel Farage and Reform UK
Rachel Reeves just dropped biggest clue yet Labour fears Nigel Farage and Reform UK

Comments

POLL: Should Nigel Farage get a knighthood in King Charles's Birthday Honours
POLL: Should Nigel Farage get a knighthood in King Charles’s Birthday Honours

Comments

Keir Starmer's U-turns explained - from Winter Fuel Payments to WASPI women
Keir Starmer’s U-turns explained – from Winter Fuel Payments to WASPI women

Comments

READ MORE: Macron takes 10-word swipe at Trump as he arrives in Greenland

Sir Keir entered Downing Street on July 5, 2024, after securing a comfortable majority for Labour in the general election.

However, despite the scale of his victory, Britain Elects noted: “He began his premiership with just four-in-ten Britons holding a favourable view towards him, and a touch under that holding an unfavourable view.”

The tracker added: “On the net numbers he was in the green. But compared to David Cameron, the last Prime Minister to come in on an election win, these numbers pale poorly.”

The picture worsens when comparing Sir Keir’s trajectory with that of previous Prime Ministers. Britain Elects noted: “Whereas Starmer’s ratings plateaued around day 300, Gordon Brown’s plummeted.

Don’t miss…
Fury as 100,000 asylum seekers could be given taxpayer-funded homes [INSIGHT]
‘Keir Starmer eyes post-Brexit win with three priorities for UK and Canada’ [ANALYSIS]
Rachel Reeves’ spending plans ‘blown out the window’ in fiery BBC clash [PICTURES]

PMQs: Kemi Badenoch accuses Keir Starmer of being a ‘coward’

0 seconds of 58 secondsVolume 90%

“And Theresa May’s – whose own performance in the 2017 General Election campaign ruptured what goodwill the voters had for her – went from +16 to -16.”

The site also said: “For much of his leadership of the Labour Party, between 30 and 40% of us did not know what to think of Keir Starmer. Only after the Liz Truss mini-budget did opinion warm to the Leader of the Opposition. But relative to other LOTOs, his were still a muted series of ratings.”

It continued: “Approval ratings are important to measure that public goodwill. But in isolation they can be deceiving.

“Boris Johnson and David Cameron both went to the country in the net negative. But it didn’t matter, for their Labour counterparts were vastly more unpopular.”

Sir Keir has faced a turbulent first year in office. His Government has been criticised for a string of policy reversals – including on the two-child benefit cap, VAT on private schools, and the decision to delay housing reforms. At the same time, Labour has been hit by growing unease on the backbenches, particularly over its handling of Gaza and migration.

Industrial unrest has persisted in key sectors, while widespread winter flooding earlier this year put pressure on Downing Street’s response capabilities.

Meanwhile Chancellor Rachel Reeves’s spending review last week has faced criticism for its potential to lead to significant tax increases and spending cuts.

Analysts warn that the government’s fiscal strategy may be unsustainable, with public spending at record highs and taxes also at elevated levels.

The Institute for Fiscal Studies cautioned that Reeves’s approach could result in “sharp trade-offs,” potentially undermining public trust in politicians

LEAVE A RESPONSE

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *